Butterflies When Implied Volatility Is High

· Butterflies

Navy card with the label Butterflies and the headline Butterflies when implied volatility is high

A long butterfly buys one option at a low strike, sells two at a middle strike and buys one at a high strike, all in the same expiration. It pays the most if the price finishes at the middle strike, and it can lose no more than the debit. When implied volatility jumps, the price of a centered butterfly falls, sometimes to half of what it cost in a quiet market. The maximum payoff stays the same, so the ratio of reward to risk suddenly looks generous. That cheapness is real, but it has a reason. A butterfly is a bet on one narrow band of outcomes, and high implied volatility means the market is pricing a wide spread of outcomes. The low price is the market's estimate of how rarely the band gets hit.

The rules first

  • A cheap fly in high volatility is a lower probability, not a discount. The debit roughly tracks how much of the expected distribution falls inside the wings. Wider expected moves mean less of it does.
  • Put the break-even range next to the expected move. If the expected move to expiration is two or three times wider than the distance to either break-even, the trade needs the market to move much less than it is priced to.
  • Near the body, a long butterfly is short vega. A drop in implied volatility with the price near the middle strike lifts the value before expiration. That is the second way a fly can work in a high-volatility market.
  • Near the wings, the sign flips. With the price out near a wing, a drop in implied volatility lowers the value. A volatility crush helps only if the price stays close to the body.
  • Choose the wing width against the expected move. Wider wings cost more and pay less per dollar at risk, but they cover more of the range the market is pricing.

Why the price falls when volatility rises

At expiration, a butterfly is worth something only if the price lands between the wings. Before expiration, its value is close to the probability-weighted value of landing in that band. When implied volatility rises, the market's distribution of outcomes spreads out. Less of it sits near the middle strike, so the fly is worth less. Nothing about the structure changed. The same strikes, the same maximum payoff and the same maximum loss now sit under a flatter distribution.

This is why the payoff ratio of a butterfly is not a good guide on its own. A 1-to-5 or 1-to-6 ratio looks better than a 1-to-2 ratio, but the ratio is the price of a probability. A higher ratio usually means a lower chance of collecting a meaningful part of it.

Worked example (illustrative numbers only)

Every number here is an illustrative example, not a quote, priced with a standard model and no interest or dividends. Options carry a 100 multiplier.

The setup. An index fund trades at 100. With 30 days to expiration, buy the 95 call, sell two 100 calls and buy the 105 call. At 20% implied volatility this 5-wide butterfly costs about 1.64. At 40% implied volatility the same butterfly costs about 0.86, a little more than half.

At expiration. The most the 5-wide fly can be worth is 5.00, at exactly 100. Bought for 0.86, it breaks even at about 95.86 and 104.14, roughly 4.1% either side of the strike. Maximum gain 4.14, maximum loss 0.86: a ratio of nearly 1 to 5.

The expected move. At 40% implied volatility, a one-standard-deviation move over 30 days is about 11.5%, roughly 88.5 to 111.5. The break-even range covers a bit more than a third of that. At 20% implied volatility the expected move is about 5.7%, and the break-even range of the 1.64 fly (about 96.6 to 103.4) covers more than half of it. The cheaper fly is cheaper because it is less likely to finish in the money.

Halfway through: the vega effect. Fifteen days later, the price is still at 100. What the fly is worth depends on where implied volatility has gone:

  • Volatility still at 40%: about 1.19. Gain 0.33, or $33 per spread.
  • Volatility down to 28%: about 1.65. Gain 0.79.
  • Volatility down to 20%: about 2.19. Gain 1.33.

With the price at the body, falling volatility more than doubles the gain from time decay alone. This is the short-vega side of the butterfly.

Halfway through, away from the body. Now suppose the price has moved to 90 instead, past the lower wing:

  • Volatility still at 40%: about 0.52. Loss 0.34.
  • Volatility down to 28%: about 0.35. Loss 0.51.
  • Volatility down to 20%: about 0.15. Loss 0.71.

Out at the wing, the same volatility drop makes things worse. Lower volatility shrinks the chance that the price travels back to the body before expiration. The fly needs both conditions: calmer markets and a price that stays near the middle strike.

A wider fly. The 90/100/110 call butterfly at 40% implied volatility costs about 3.28. Maximum value 10.00, so the maximum gain is 6.72 and the ratio is about 1 to 2. Break-evens sit near 93.3 and 106.7, about 6.7% either side, which covers close to 60% of the 11.5% expected move. Halfway through, with the price at 94 and volatility down to 28%, the wide fly is worth about 3.90, a gain, where the 5-wide fly at the same price is worth about 0.96, a small gain on a much smaller debit. The wider fly risks more dollars per spread, so the position size has to come down to keep the same maximum loss.

When a butterfly in high volatility tends to make sense

  • When the trader has a specific reason to expect a smaller move than priced before expiration, such as a scheduled event that is likely to resolve the uncertainty, and accepts that the market may be right.
  • When the trade is about the volatility drop as much as the pin, and the plan is to take the gain before expiration if volatility falls with the price near the body, rather than hold for the last few days.
  • When the wings are chosen against the expected move, often wider than in a quiet market, with position size cut to match the larger debit.
  • When the full debit is a loss the account can take several times in a row. Low-probability trades lose often, even when they are priced fairly.

Common mistakes

  • Buying the ratio. A 1-to-5 payoff ratio in a high-volatility market is the market's price on a narrow outcome, not a bargain.
  • Using quiet-market wing widths. Wings sized for a 5% expected move leave most of an 11% expected move outside the tent.
  • Counting on a volatility crush to rescue a fly that has drifted to a wing. Away from the body, falling volatility lowers the value.
  • Holding into the last days for the full payoff. Gamma near the body is largest at the end. The 5.00 at the middle strike is a point, not a range, and small moves swing the value sharply.
  • Sizing by the small debit. A cheap fly makes a large position feel harmless. Size by the total debit you are willing to lose.

A short high-volatility butterfly checklist

  1. Write down the implied volatility and compute the expected move to expiration.
  2. Mark the break-even range and compare it with the expected move.
  3. Model the fly halfway to expiration at the body and at each wing, with volatility unchanged and lower.
  4. Compare at least two wing widths and their debit, ratio and break-evens.
  5. Note any scheduled event before expiration and why the move should be smaller than priced.
  6. Size so the full debit is an acceptable loss, and write the profit target and exit before entry.

Pin risk, skew and choosing wing widths for butterflies are covered in depth in Trading Butterflies.

Related reading

This post is for education only. It is not investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security or option. Options involve risk and are not suitable for all investors. All numbers above are illustrative examples, not market data.

Get new desk notes by email